Panthers Greg Hardy guilty of assaulting female, communicating threats

The Charlotte ObserverJuly 15, 2014 

— Carolina Panthers defensive end Greg Hardy was found guilty Tuesday of assaulting a female and communicating threats stemming from a May 13 confrontation.

Hardy has appealed the verdict and will be granted a jury trial.

He had been sentenced to 18 months' probation. A 60-day jail sentence was suspended.

"The court is entirely convinced Hardy is guilty of assault on a female and communicating threats," said District Judge Becky Thorne Tin in announcing her ruling about 9 p.m.

In morning testimony, Nicole Holder said she was terrified during a late-night struggle in May with her then-boyfriend Hardy, who she said choked her in a jealous rage in his uptown condo.

"He looked me in my eyes and he told me he was going to kill me," said Holder, 24, an EpiCentre nightclub waitress who said she used to live with Hardy.

"I was so scared I wanted to die. When he loosened his grip slightly, I said, 'Just do it. Kill me.' "

Hardy was ordered to not have any contact with Holder.

Hardy had earlier pleaded not guilty to both misdemeanor charges. Taking the stand Tuesday night, Hardy said he didn't hit or threaten Holder. He said he asked her to leave his condo that night because he had to get up early to attend football practice. She refused, he said, and threatened to go home and kill herself, asking, "Is that what you want?"

Hardy said Holder asked him, "Do you want to see crazy? I'll show you crazy." Then, he said, she threw herself into the bathtub. The defense would argue that her injuries were self-inflicted.

Holder said she met Hardy nearly two years ago when he dated her then-roommate. She said she began dating Hardy last September. She said she moved in with Hardy; he said they didn't live together.

Their relationship was good as late as January when she accompanied him to Hawaii, where he played in the NFL Pro Bowl, she testified. She had expected to fly with him to the Super Bowl in New York, she said, but things changed. At the airport in Hawaii, she found that he had changed her ticket and made the destination Charlotte.

Hardy said he broke up with Holder at the Pro Bowl. "I couldn't argue that much. I need to focus on football," he said. He said he continued to have sexual relations with her after that.

Holder said Hardy had become more controlling over time and their relationship soured after she had moved in with him. She said Hardy "cheated" on her many times. But, she said, even after the Super Bowl, they were still working on their relationship.

SPILLED CHAMPAGNE

After Holder testified for more than two hours, the defense began its case around 5 p.m.. The trial lasted later than usual because Tin said the court had to delay multiple cases Tuesday and couldn't afford to do that again Wednesday.

A security guard at the EpiCentre testified that Holder was ranting and raving as she followed Hardy out of the EpiCentre two nights before the alleged assault.

Laura Iwanicki, a friend of Holder's, said that the Holder-Hardy relationship was "either really good or really bad." She said she was with Holder in Hardy's apartment the night of the alleged assault and that Holder told her, "(Hardy) hasn't seen crazy yet.

Hardy became upset earlier that day, Holder said, when he spilled a glass of champagne and was called for a "party foul" � an expression yelled out when someone does something socially unacceptable. He left, then came back.

"I wasn't angry," Hardy said about the "party foul." "I just needed an excuse to leave. I didn't want to be around Nicole."

Holder said that later she and Hardy went to the luxury Charlotte nightclub Bubble at the EpiCentre. Hardy spent more than $2,000, she said.

Then, Holder said Hardy grew agitated at her and, "to top everything off, a Nelly song came on." She had earlier told police that Hardy was upset with her because of a short-term relationship she had with Nelly, a Grammy-winning rap artist and a part owner of the NBA's Charlotte Hornets, at a time when she and Hardy had broken up.

After going to the condo, Hardy began hurling insults at her, calling her a whore and a slut, Holder testified, then backhanded her into a wall. She said he slammed her onto a sofa strewn with firearms, and then choked her.

When he loosened his grip, Holder said, she struck him in the temple with her shoe. Sammy Curtis, a friend of Hardy's, came in and tackled her, she said.

Curtis, though, later said Hardy calmly asked Holder to leave. Curtis said he saw Holder swing at Hardy.

Hardy said, "I don't fight. I don't even fight dudes."

Chris Fialko, Hardy's attorney tore into Holder on the stand, saying she attacked Hardy in a cocaine and alcohol-fury the night of the incident. Holder admitted Tuesday to using cocaine that night. Fialko asked Holder repeatedly if her accusations were true, why she was not more badly injured. And he asked if she feared for her life, why she didn't pick up and use a gun.

"I wouldn't know how to use it," she said.

FIRST CALL TO POLICE

Holder said she heard Hardy call 911 while Curtis had his hand over her mouth. Holder testified that she thought she was going to jail for something she didn't do. Holder said she didn't make a statement to police when they arrived because she was scared and she said she told officers she'd fallen down the stairs.

Christina Lawrence, who was in the condo during the confrontation, testified that she'd been drinking shots earlier at Hardy's. She said she met Hardy and friends a day earlier and had not previously met Holder.

Lawrence said she saw two guns against the window and a few on the bar. "Me and my girlfriend were like, why so many?" Lawrence said.

Lawrence said she was sleeping in a front bedroom and heard arguing, scuffling and someone being slammed into a wall. She said she heard someone say: "What are you going to do, break my arm?"

She said she did not see an assault take place but became frightened and left the apartment. She said she persuaded a security guard at Hardy's building to call police.

POLICE ARRIVE AT CONDO

CMPD officer Christopher Martin, who responded to the call, testified that Holder appeared upset and initially didn't want to talk to police. Martin said Holder told police that Hardy was upset about her relationship with Nelly.

Martin said Hardy's face had been scraped. Three photos of Hardy, who stands 6-foot-4 and weighs 290 pounds, were entered into evidence that show a rash on his inner forearm and a scratch under his cheekbone.

CMPD officer Abraham Kim took photos of Holder showing redness to her chest and neck, scratches and bruises to her arm, elbow and back.

Holder has accused Hardy of throwing her to the floor and into a bathtub, strangling her, slamming her into a futon that was covered with guns, and threatening to shoot her if she told anyone about the fight.

Hardy's attorney noted that police found no guns the evening of the altercation, but Martin said that "in 45 minutes they could have cleaned. We can go scenarios all day long." Complying with a court order in May, Hardy had turned over 10 guns, including at least six military-type, semi-automatic rifles and three 12-gauge shotguns.

Panthers and NFL officials have said they would wait until the legal process has taken its course before deciding on any possible punishment for Hardy.

The Panthers placed the franchise tag on Hardy this year after he tied Kevin Greene's single-season team record with 15 sacks in 2013. Hardy is guaranteed $13.1 million this year under the tag.

Tuesday afternoon was the deadline for the Panthers to sign Hardy to a long-term deal.

Bellingham Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service